Positively Blue

Positively Blue

Share this post

Positively Blue
Positively Blue
Positively Ranting
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
User's avatar
Discover more from Positively Blue
Content covering New York City Football Club. Opinionated. Biased. Positive. Good vibes only.
Already have an account? Sign in

Positively Ranting

John Harbour's avatar
John Harbour
Jun 04, 2023

Share this post

Positively Blue
Positively Blue
Positively Ranting
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Share
Photo: NYCFC

Cushing out. Deila out, Dome out. Vieira out. It must be June in New York. Two different matches were played yesterday; those with hyper-critical vision saw a team in crisis. Every failure to score an indictment of Cushing and Lee. A team that deserves to be derided, jeered, and informed that they have to win. They must win. As if that thought hasn’t occurred to them. Then there are those of us who saw a team wiping off the dust of the mid-week failure, ignore the fact of losing a starter due to some yet to be released accusation, and put in a gritty performance. We saw a well-played match against one of the top keepers in the league who did his job well and if not for a lucky assist from the woodwork, would have added a loss to his tally.

The only indication of poor coaching that I saw was that the team is not quick enough in transition or in moving the ball up the pitch. They tend to go to the lateral pass rather than push forward and attack. They also tend to think a bit too much when on the ball. Those decisions need to be a second faster.  

But people see what they expect to see. The youth soccer teams that filled the surrounding sections saw a match where they chanted and cheered, shouted and screamed. All for the love of their club. Kids see the beautiful game. They focus on the game part. They enjoy the experience. Adults see something that needs to be fixed. Frustrations that need to be shared. And a loss or draw is seen as a personal offense. 

It’s easy being a supporter when the team is winning. We all came into this experience back in 2015 without knowing what type of team we would support… top of the table or relegated in any other league. Fortunately, we were given the first. But it is in how we handle our side having a down season that shows our true nature. What type of supporter are you or wish to be? Do you scream at the moon, thinking that you actually have agency with the Front Office, or do you understand how fickle the game actually is and choose to support the team, and each other, when we’re at the bottom of a cycle.

#NYCFC Twitter is only a fraction of the fan base and out of that only 50 or so of us are really active and vocal. A few more than most. And quite frankly, it’s getting boring. If you have a different opinion from one of those who want to burn the team to the ground during any stretch of poor form you are either not a real supporter, don’t expect the best out of the team, are an apologist, or don’t really know the game. 

I offer another perspective. Maybe, we are just as passionate, just as knowledgeable, and love the badge the same amount. Maybe the difference is that winning is secondary to why we pay the cost of admission. Maybe our demands are more simple. Our only demand is that the team play with heart and leave it all on the pitch. That we are able to enjoy the experience of live professional football with others who love the sport. And that the team recognizes our love for them and the badge and respects us enough to give it all knowing that we are committed. Win, lose, or draw, we will have their back. We will criticize their level of play, but in the end we will still stand up for them, even the coach. This is MLS. Not the Prem. No one deserves to be fired mid-campaign for a bad run of play during a season of reconfiguration. And those who disagree with others on the bird site do not deserve to be mocked and derided because they have a different take on what it means to be a supporter. 

Stay positive,

The Man in Seat 9

Want to show your support for this free content? You can leave a onetime tip by clicking here.

Subscribe to Positively Blue

By John Harbour · Launched 2 years ago
Content covering New York City Football Club. Opinionated. Biased. Positive. Good vibes only.

Share this post

Positively Blue
Positively Blue
Positively Ranting
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Share

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
A Brighter Shade of Blue
Supporters are a funny bunch.
Mar 29, 2023 â€¢ 
John Harbour

Share this post

Positively Blue
Positively Blue
A Brighter Shade of Blue
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
FC Dallas: Minor League Ball
In the heart of Gatsby’s Valley of Ashes, A blue and white firebird, the likes of which never seen before, rose from the dust and ashes as a symbol of…
Apr 26, 2023 â€¢ 
John Harbour

Share this post

Positively Blue
Positively Blue
FC Dallas: Minor League Ball
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Storms of Spring
It is only April, and like the daffodils of early spring, grumblings of "Cushing out" are popping up around the NYCFC online community.
Apr 12, 2023 â€¢ 
John Harbour

Share this post

Positively Blue
Positively Blue
Storms of Spring
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

Ready for more?

© 2025 John Harbour
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

Create your profile

User's avatar

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.